In the realm of cargo management solutions, two prominent options stand out: the TMS 800 LB Rack and the Aluminum Truck Bed Rack. Each of these systems offers unique benefits and considerations that cater to different user needs. As I delve into a comparative analysis of these two racks, I aim to explore their construction, weight capacity, pricing, and overall functionality, providing a clearer understanding of which might be the better choice for various applications.
**Adventure Ready
7.8
The TMS 800 LB Low Profile Extendable Non-Drilling Steel Pickup Truck Bed Rack is a sturdy and adjustable solution for transporting larger items like bikes, skis, or rooftop tents, with a weight capacity of 800 lbs. This easy-to-install rack requires no drilling and is compatible with various Toyota models and trucks featuring utility track systems, offering adjustable widths from 5 to 7 feet.
**Versatile Transport
8.4
The Aluminum Truck Bed Rack offers a sturdy, rust-resistant solution with an impressive 800lbs capacity for securely transporting larger items like kayaks and ladders. Its adjustable design ensures compatibility with various pickup trucks, making it a versatile addition for outdoor enthusiasts and contractors alike.
TMS 800 LB Rack
Material
Heavy-duty steel
Weight Capacity
800 lbs
Installation Method
No drilling or modifications required
Adjustability
Adjustable width from 5 ft to 7 ft, height 21 in
Compatibility
Compatible with Tacoma, Tundra, and trucks with utility track systems
Aluminum Truck Bed Rack
Material
Rust-resistant aluminum
Weight Capacity
800 lbs (600 lbs in motion)
Installation Method
Requires drilling for stabilization
Adjustability
Adjustable width from 71.25″ to 80.11″, height from 11″ to 12.79″
Compatibility
Universal fit for most full-size pickup trucks including Ford F-Series, Chevrolet Silverado, Dodge Ram
TMS 800 LB Rack
Benefits
- Sturdy construction suitable for supporting rooftop tents and other loads
- Affordable price compared to higher-end alternatives
- Easy to assemble with common tools, making installation straightforward
Aluminum Truck Bed Rack
Benefits
- Strong and sturdy construction with an 800lbs capacity
- Adjustable design that can be customized to fit various truck models
- Excellent value for money compared to name brands, with effective packaging and ease of installation
TMS 800 LB Rack
Drawbacks
- Poor paint quality leading to rust and oxidation within a short period of use
- Lacks proper fit for certain truck models, requiring additional modifications for installation
Aluminum Truck Bed Rack
Drawbacks
- Missing parts and installation directions
- Bolts for attachment could have been longer
Comparison table
| Feature | TMS 800 LB Low Profile Extendable Non-Drilling Steel Pickup Truck Bed Rack Sport Bar | Truck Bed Rack, Aluminum Bed Rack for Pickup Truck |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Steel | Aluminum |
| Weight Capacity | 800 lbs | 800 lbs |
| Installation Type | Non-Drilling | Adjustable Universal, potentially drill-free |
| Design | Low Profile Extendable | Adjustable Height, Low Profile |
| Use Cases | Suitable for rooftop tents, kayaks, bikes | Ideal for various gear including kayaks, bikes, tents |
| Bar Length | 21 inches | Universal Adjustable |
| Durability and Maintenance | High durability but may rust over time without treatment | Resistant to rust with easy maintenance |
| Adjustability | Fixed with extendable features | Fully adjustable for different setups |
| Weight | Heavier due to steel construction | Lightweight, easier to handle |
Unique Selling Points (USPs)
TMS 800 LB Low Profile Extendable Non-Drilling Steel Pickup Truck Bed Rack Sport Bar
- Non-Drilling Installation: Easy to install without altering your vehicle.
- Extendable Feature: Can adapt to various applications, offering versatility.
- Sturdy Steel Construction: Designed for heavy-duty use, suitable for carrying substantial loads.
Truck Bed Rack, Aluminum Bed Rack for Pickup Truck
- Adjustable Height: Can be modified to fit different truck models and gear types.
- Lightweight Design: Easy to handle and install, making it user-friendly.
- Rust-Resistant: Made from aluminum, ensuring longevity and low maintenance.
Pros and Cons
TMS 800 LB Low Profile Extendable Non-Drilling Steel Pickup Truck Bed Rack
Pros:
- Solid construction ideal for heavy-duty use.
- Versatile for various activities like camping or kayaking.
Cons:
- Heavier construction may require more effort for handling.
- Potential for rust if not treated properly.
Truck Bed Rack, Aluminum Bed Rack for Pickup Truck
Pros:
- Lightweight and easier for installation.
- Adjustable height allows for customization depending on needs.
Cons:
- May not handle as heavy loads as steel racks in extreme conditions.
- Adjustment may require tools and additional time.
Use-Cases
- TMS Rack: Best suited for users frequently using a pickup truck for heavy loads like rooftop tents, camping gear, or large recreational equipment.
- Aluminum Bed Rack: Ideal for those looking for flexibility with lighter loads, such as bikes and kayaks, and who prefer an easy-to-install system.
Conclusive Assessment
While both products have a weight capacity of 800 lbs and serve similar purposes, each has unique strengths. The TMS 800 LB Low Profile Extendable Non-Drilling Steel Rack excels in durability and is better suited for heavy loads, making it a great choice for rugged use. On the other hand, the Aluminum Bed Rack offers ease of installation and adjustability, catering to users who may seek a more versatile and lighter solution.
Conditional Winner
- If you prioritize heavy-duty capability and rugged durability, the TMS Rack is the winner.
- If you need adjustability, easy handling, and lighter loads, the Aluminum Rack will serve you better.
Final Summary
In conclusion, both racks are excellent choices depending on your specific needs. The TMS 800 LB Low Profile Rack is ideal for heavy-duty applications and rugged adventures, while the Aluminum Bed Rack allows for versatility and easy handling for lighter use. Consider your typical cargo needs, installation preferences, and sole requirements to make an informed choice.
Great comparison! Have you thought about including the Yakima OverHaul HD in the next post? I think it’s worth a look!
Thanks for breaking this down! I totally agree that the TMS 800 LB Rack offers better value for the price. Aluminum racks can get super pricey!
You’re welcome! Glad you found it helpful. Totally get what you mean about the pricing—value is key!
Has anyone tried using the TMS rack for hauling bikes? Curious if it holds up well for that purpose!
Yes, many users have had success using the TMS rack for bikes! Just ensure to use proper tie-downs for security. Great question!
I think the pricing on the Aluminum Truck Bed Rack is a bit steep for what you get. You can find more affordable options that don’t compromise on quality!
That’s a fair point! There are definitely budget-friendly alternatives out there that still offer good quality. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
I don’t know, I think the Aluminum Truck Bed Rack looks way nicer! But I guess it depends on personal taste and what you need it for.
Totally understand where you’re coming from! Aesthetics can be a big factor for many people. It’s all about what fits your style and needs.
I love my Thule TracRac! It’s super durable and has held up well over time. Would have loved to see that compared too!
Great choice! Thule TracRac is well-regarded for its durability. We’ll keep that in mind for future comparisons!
I recently installed a rooftop tent on my TMS rack, and it’s been awesome! Just make sure you distribute the weight evenly. Anyone else have tips?
Awesome to hear you’re enjoying your rooftop tent! Weight distribution is definitely crucial. Thanks for sharing your experience!
Can anyone recommend a good rack for a Toyota Tacoma? I’m torn between these two!
Hey! Many Tacoma owners swear by the TMS 800 LB Rack for its sturdiness, but some prefer the lightweight nature of aluminum racks. It really depends on your usage!
Thanks for the suggestion! The Yakima OverHaul HD is definitely a solid option, and we’ll consider it for future comparisons.