When it comes to embarking on an adventure, whether it’s a weekend getaway or a cross-country road trip, transporting your gear safely and efficiently is crucial. I understand the frustration of packing and unpacking, worrying about space, and ensuring everything arrives in perfect condition. That’s where roof cargo carriers come into play, offering a solution to maximize your vehicle’s storage capacity. In this blog post, I will guide you through the key differences between hard shell and soft shell roof cargo carriers. By examining their features, advantages, and limitations, I aim to help you make an informed decision that aligns with your travel needs and lifestyle. Let’s dive in and find out which option is the best fit for you.
What are Hard Shell Roof Cargo Carriers?
Hard shell roof cargo carriers are specialized storage solutions designed to be mounted on the rooftops of vehicles. Constructed from robust materials such as plastic or fiberglass, these carriers offer a secure and spacious option for transporting everything from camping gear to sports equipment. Their solid structure distinguishes them from soft-shelled alternatives, providing numerous advantages for travelers, outdoor enthusiasts, and anyone needing extra cargo space.
Construction and Materials
Hard shell roof cargo carriers are predominantly made from high-quality, durable materials like:
- High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE): This plastic offers exceptional strength and resistance to impact and UV degradation.
- Fiberglass: Known for its lightweight and stress-resistant properties, fiberglass enhances the aerodynamic features of the carrier.
These materials work together to create a sturdy enclosure that can withstand varying weather conditions and protect your belongings from the elements.
Benefits of Hard Shell Roof Cargo Carriers
1. Durability
The rigid structure of hard shell carriers ensures they maintain their shape and integrity over time. Unlike soft carriers, which may sag or tear, hard shell models resist deformities and can protect your gear more effectively.
2. Enhanced Security for Belongings
Hard shell cargo carriers typically feature locking mechanisms, providing an additional layer of security against theft. This is an essential consideration for travelers who may make frequent stops along their journey.
3. Aerodynamic Design for Improved Fuel Efficiency
The sleek design of many hard shell cargo carriers minimizes wind resistance. This aerodynamic shape not only helps to stabilize the vehicle at high speeds but also contributes to fuel efficiency, potentially saving you money on gas during long trips.
4. Versatility
Many hard shell carriers are designed for diverse applications, from carrying skis and kayaks to accommodating luggage for family vacations. Their modular nature means they can be quickly installed and removed, enhancing convenience.
Popular Brands and Models
When considering a hard shell roof cargo carrier, numerous reputable brands and models are available, each with unique features that cater to different needs:
- Thule Motion XT
- Capacity: Up to 16 cu ft
- Dimensions: 75 x 36 x 18 in
- Key Feature: Easy to open from both sides with integrated SKS locking system. Known for its sleek design and ample storage.
- Yakima SkyBox Carbonite
- Capacity: Ranges from 12 to 21 cu ft
- Dimensions: Varies by model
- Key Feature: Lightweight construction with a durable ABS plastic shell and a super cool aerodynamic shape.
- INNO Wedge 660
- Capacity: 13 cu ft
- Dimensions: 61 x 25 x 15 in
- Key Feature: Stylish and durable with a fastening system that fits most crossbars.
- SportRack Vista XL
- Capacity: 18 cu ft
- Dimensions: 59 x 24 x 22 in
- Key Feature: Affordable option with a distinguished aerodynamic shape, suitable for various vehicle sizes.
Comparison Table
| Feature | Thule Motion XT | Yakima SkyBox Carbonite | INNO Wedge 660 | SportRack Vista XL |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 16 cu ft | 12-21 cu ft | 13 cu ft | 18 cu ft |
| Dimensions | 75 x 36 x 18 in | Varies | 61 x 25 x 15 in | 59 x 24 x 22 in |
| Material | ABS Plastic | ABS & Carbonite | ABS Plastic | ABS Plastic |
| Locking System | Integrated SKS | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Weight | 42 lbs | Ranges (10-15 lbs) | 24 lbs | 39 lbs |
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re planning a weekend getaway, a road trip with family, or need extra space for sporting equipment, hard shell roof cargo carriers offer a functional and secure solution. By choosing a high-quality product from trusted brands, you can enhance your vehicle’s storage capabilities while ensuring the safety and protection of your belongings during transit.
What are Soft Shell Roof Cargo Carriers?
Soft shell roof cargo carriers are versatile storage solutions designed for those who want to maximize their vehicle’s carrying capacity without the bulk and weight of conventional hard shell carriers. Made from fabric-based materials, these carriers offer a blend of flexibility, lightweight design, and affordability, making them an appealing choice for many travelers.
Fabric-Based Construction and Flexibility
The primary feature of soft shell roof cargo carriers is their fabric-based construction. Typically made from durable materials such as nylon or polyester, these carriers are designed to withstand various environmental conditions while remaining lightweight.
- Materials: Many soft shell carriers use waterproof materials or feature waterproof zippers, providing a level of water resistance ideal for short trips or sudden rain showers. Examples include the Thule Outbound and Rooftop Cargo Carrier from Rage Powersports, which employ high-quality weather-resistant fabric.
- Flexibility: Unlike hard shell carriers, soft shell options can conform to the unique shape of your load, making them suitable for a variety of cargo types. This is particularly advantageous when transporting items like camping gear, sports equipment, or luggage that may not fit neatly into a rigid structure.
Lightweight Nature and Ease of Storage
One of the significant advantages of soft shell roof cargo carriers is their lightweight nature.
- Ease of Handling: Weighing significantly less than their hard shell counterparts, these carriers add minimal extra load to your vehicle, enhancing fuel efficiency and overall handling. For example, the Goplus Rooftop Cargo Carrier weighs just around 5 pounds, making it easy to install and remove.
- Storage Convenience: When not in use, soft shell carriers can be folded flat for convenient storage. They require far less space, perfect for apartment dwellers or those with limited garage space. For instance, the Keeper 07203-2 soft shell carrier can be easily tucked away in a closet or the trunk without taking up much room.
Affordability Compared to Hard Shell Options
Soft shell carriers often come at a fraction of the price of hard shell models, making them an attractive choice for budget-conscious consumers.
- Price Range: While hard shell carriers can range from several hundred to over a thousand dollars, many top-tier soft shell options, like the CargoLoc 2-Layer Roof Top Cargo Carrier, are available for under $100. This affordability allows more people to access extra storage without breaking the bank.
Pros and Cons of Soft Shell Roof Cargo Carriers
Pros
- Water Resistance: Many soft shell carriers are designed with water-resistant materials, suitable for light rain and moisture. However, it’s essential to check the product specifications for details. Brands like Rightline Gear offer options that are specifically noted for their water-resistant features.
- Flexibility in Size and Shape: Their adaptable design means you can pack a range of items—whether it’s a bulky tent, sleeping bags, or a cooler without worrying about space limitations.
- Compatibility: Soft shell carriers can generally fit on most vehicles with roof racks or crossbars. For instance, the VersaPak Vehicle Cargo Carrier is versatile enough to be used on cars, SUVs, and trucks alike.
Cons
- Less Protection: Compared to hard shell carriers, soft shell options may offer less protection against theft or damage. While hard shell carriers are typically lockable, most soft shell models are not.
- Durability: Although many are made from high-quality fabrics, soft shell carriers may not withstand long-term, heavy-duty use, especially if they are subjected to rough weather conditions consistently.
- Limited Load Capacity: Given their lightweight nature and flexibility, soft shell cargo carriers might be limited regarding their maximum load capacity, often ranging between 100-200 pounds. It’s critical to adhere to the manufacturer’s recommendations to avoid damage to your vehicle.
| Feature/Brand | Thule Outbound | Keeper 07203-2 | Goplus Rooftop Cargo Carrier | Rightline Gear |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weight | 9 lbs | 5 lbs | 5 lbs | 9 lbs |
| Water Resistance | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Max Load Capacity | 110 lbs | 100 lbs | 110 lbs | 100 lbs |
| Price Range | $149 | $58 | $45 | $119 |
| Compatibility | Cars, SUVs | Cars, SUVs | Trucks, SUVs | Cars, SUVs |
Exploring the advantages and disadvantages of soft shell roof cargo carriers can help you make an informed decision tailored to your travel needs and budget.
Making the Right Choice for Your Travel Needs
In conclusion, both hard shell and soft shell roof cargo carriers have their unique strengths and weaknesses that cater to different travel needs. Hard shell carriers offer superior protection and durability, making them ideal for long-distance journeys or harsh weather conditions. On the other hand, soft shell carriers are often more lightweight, flexible, and budget-friendly, which can be advantageous for casual travelers or those with limited storage space. Ultimately, the choice between the two should be guided by your travel habits, budget, and vehicle type. I recommend considering how often you travel, the type of gear you plan to carry, and the conditions you’ll be facing, ensuring that your selected carrier enhances your overall travel experience.
I think hard shells are better for long trips, but anyone else have thoughts on their storage hassles when not in use? They take up so much space!
Good point! Hard shells can be bulky to store. If space is tight, consider a model that can be mounted on a hitch or one that has a more compact design, like the INNO Wedge.
Could you expand on the security features of soft shell carriers? I’m worried about theft when I stop during road trips.
Sure! Soft shells usually don’t have built-in locks, but you can use cable locks to secure them to your vehicle. There are also some soft carriers with locking zippers, like the Thule Ascent, which add an extra layer of security.
Has anyone tried the Yakima SkyBox hard shell? I’ve heard mixed reviews about wind noise. Anyone experience that?
Yes, the Yakima SkyBox does have some noise issues at higher speeds. A good tip is to position it more towards the back of the roof or try using a wind fairing to reduce that noise.
I’ve always been a fan of soft shell carriers! They’re so easy to pack and can fit oddly shaped items. Anyone else have strong feelings about them?
I tried a soft shell carrier for a road trip and it leaked during a rainstorm. Really regretted not going for hard shell. Any tips on waterproofing the soft ones?
That’s a bummer! For soft shells, I recommend using waterproof bags inside for valuables and treating the outer fabric with a water repellent spray. It can make a big difference!
Can anyone recommend a good soft shell carrier for camping gear? I’m looking for something that holds up well against the elements.
Check out the Rightline Gear Sport 3! It’s super durable and has a waterproof design, plus it’s easy to set up on most vehicles.
I’d love to read more about the differences in aerodynamics between the two types. Any other articles you’d recommend?
Great idea! I suggest checking out the article on ‘Aerodynamics in Roof Racks’ from Car and Driver. It dives into how different carriers can impact fuel efficiency.
Absolutely! Soft shell carriers, like the Thule Outbound, do offer a lot of flexibility and are often more affordable. Thanks for sharing your preference!
I used a hard shell carrier on a recent trip. Big win for organizing everything! Just curious if anyone has tips to avoid scratching the car roof when loading/unloading?
That’s awesome! To prevent scratches, consider using a soft mat or blanket when placing the carrier on your roof. It creates a buffer and protects your vehicle’s finish.